Tuesday, February 2, 2010

Who offers OPD Coverage as a part of Health Insurance in India

Who offers OPD Coverage as a part of Health Insurance in India

This is a very common question which we come across from our customers. In fact those who are familiar with USA or are returning from there find it very strange that most of the Indian insurance companies have products which do not cover OPD.

The exceptions are;
ICICI Lombard�s �Health Advantage Plus� and
Apollo Munich�s �Maxima� Health Insurance plan.

ICICI Lombard�s Health Advantage Plus covers OPD expenses from the first day of the policy. The objective of this policy is that policy holders can enjoy maximum benefit under Section 80D as per applicable tax laws. It also offers/ covers all OPD expenses i.e. consulting, tests or medicines.

In recent times, there has been a rise in the number of Caesarian section births. Increasingly we see more complicated deliveries, a series of pre-natal tests and medication which have resulted in higher childbirth expenses. Health insurance with OPD cover is thus beneficial for women during pregnancy and childbirth. ICICI Lombard provides maternity cover as part of the Health Advantage Plus policy.

The OPD cover may vary from Rs. 2,000 to Rs. 10,000 depending on the plan opted and the age profile of policy holder.

One can claim OPD charges only once during the policy term so one has to keep all the bills paid safely to get the reimbursements as and when the limit is reached.

The Apollo Munich�s Maxima
benefits includes , cash- less OPD expenses across trusted network of pharmacies for pharmacy bills, diagnostic centers for diagnostic tests and annual health check-up, dental and optical care centers for contact lenses, spectacles and dental treatments along with consultation with family doctors.


The maximum benefit allowable for 1 adult is Rs. 8,500 [350*3 + 500*1 + 1,000 + 2,000 + 1,000 + 1,000 + 2,000(estimated)]

In addition, both the policies do not allow, an insured person to claim OPD cost within 90 days of commencement of the policy.

If we go for a normal health insurance policy, the premium paid is much less compared to these policies; as a result we end up paying more than the benefits we may receive.

Let us see the choice with examples:

Example 1:
Mr. X aged 30 years buys individual Health Advantage Plus plan from ICICI

Sum Insured : Rs. 3,00,000
Premium paid : Rs. 16,545
Less: Tax saved : Rs. 4,964 (30%)
Net premium : Rs. 11,581

Now if he takes normal healthcare policy from New India

Sum Insured : Rs. 3,00,000
Premium paid : Rs. 3,871
Less: Tax saved : Rs. 1,161(30%)
Net premium : Rs. 2,710

So, to avail OPD coverage of Rs. 8,800 (which he will not be able to claim without unnecessary visits etc.) he pays a premium of Rs. 8,871 extra.

Example 2:
Mr. X aged 30 years buys individual Maxima plan from Apollo:

Sum Insured : Rs. 3,00,000
Premium paid : Rs. 15,216
Less: Tax saved : Rs. 4,565 (30%)
Net premium : Rs. 10,651

Now if he takes normal healthcare policy from New India:

Sum Insured : Rs. 3,00,000
Premium paid : Rs. 3,871
Less: Tax saved : Rs. 1,161 (30%)
Net premium : Rs. 2,710

So, to avail OPD coverage of Rs. 8,500 (which he will not be able to claim without unnecessary visits etc.) he pays a premium of Rs. 7,941 extra.

The conclusion drawn is by having these policies you are getting the benefit in the ratio of 1:1 only.

Monday, February 1, 2010

Should health insurance be made compulsory?

The infant mortality rate in India is 10 times that in UK; it is also far higher than whole host of other developing countries (four times that of Sri Lanka, for example). A vast majority of deaths are preventable even with our present level of income. Other key health indicators, particularly maternal mortality and nutrition are equally distressing. Amongst children below five in India, 46% are under-nourished, 36% stunted and 22% wasted. Imagine the impact on each affected family, the depth of the unnecessary human tragedy, beyond the cold statistics.

The magnitude of health crisis has not got the recognition it deserves. Civil society organizations too have not been able to mobilize widespread public awareness. Many people feel that there is a need of an action plan on healthcare.

Government has been looking for alternatives, and people will like to go for ggod facilities even though they cannot afford the cost. For the poor, sickness is not just a matter of physical ill-being but also has a deep and long-lasting economic impact and productivity loss to the nation. It also affects GDP of the country.

Indian model of healthcare has largely been a private-insurance based one and as costs of healthcare will increase so the insurance premium will also increase whether we like it or not.

While the insurance industry is capitalizing on unmet demand and we also have large number of patients through conventional healthcare facilities, there is also a huge potential for technological solutions.

The government needs to leverage the new possibilities and integrate them into a comprehensive healthcare system, rather than stepping back and leaving things only to market forces.

In the recent years the government has done a wonderful job by bringing in RSBY for the benefit of poor people ,who till recently could not afford health insurance policies on their own.

Senior citizens have been complaining about non availability of health insurance of right amount and against payable of right or we can say reasonable premium.We feel now the time has come and Health Insurance should be made compulsory at least for the senior citizens.The positive impact of this will be that this will give a good boost to the insurance industry.

The idea is from the date of start 18 months will be given for all those who are 60 + yeras to get the policy issued. Wide publicity will be given thro various media to popularize this concept. Assume Rs 2000 per person per year is given as subsidy for first 2 years.

Let us assume 200 Lakhs senior citizens avail the offer and Rs 6000 is the premium then Indian insurance industry will get additional revenue of Rs. 12,000 crores. The insured senior citizens will pay Rs 4000 while the balance Rs 2000 will be paid by the governement.

The present figure of Rs 6600 crores will be going up by Rs 12000 crores and this will take the Health Insurance Industry to new heights .We are sure the portfolio will become profitable as at present only those who are expecting to lodge claims buy insurance. This will give boost to GDP, health care infrastructure and employment to large number of doctors/nurses .technicians, IT personnel.

Let us try to push this idea and improve the health of our health insurance industry. Your comments will be appreciated.

Need for health insurance policy for millions of bed-ridden senior citizens of India

Like in any other country there are many senior citizens in India who are bed-ridden and dependent on others. Their number is increasing year by year and is going to touch very large numbers by 2025.

Recently a sample of 1,000 bed-ridden senior citizens were surveyed, 600 were from Delhi and 400 from its satellite townships.

It has been found that 4% of the 2.5 million elderly in Delhi/ NCR are bed-ridden and require round-the-clock care. At any given point of time, almost 5% to 6% senior citizens live with the threat of ailments, which may render them bed-ridden.

Approximately 65% of the bed-ridden patients were reported from among the elderly person�s category and these patients face many problems, including non-availability of care-givers, depression and nervousness, lack of cleanliness & hygiene, bedsores and high blood pressure.

It was also found that 86.1% of 1,000 reviewed were affected by physical chronic illness, heart attacks or accidents while 13.9% were suffering from different kinds of mental and psychological problems.

31% bed-ridden patients reported that they needed care-givers urgently or were without any proper care-giver. 38% patients were being taken care of by their spouses, 23% by their family members and 39% by care-givers.

There were more bed-ridden men than women � 67.5% against 32.5%. 66.5% of the patients were confined to bed for a short period (less than 12 months) while 33.5% were long-term patients. 76.5% were partially affected while 23.55 were severely affected.

There is a need for training family members to take care of the bed-ridden patients and help them accept their condition. It is imperative to initiate training programme for affected family members and relatives of bed-ridden patients so that hey can get adequate knowledge and information on how to tale care of persons confined to bed.

The question before us is that these bed ridden patients are not covered by health insurance policy because they are suffering while being at home and they are not in hospital.

We will welcome an innovative product from at least one Insurance company which will take care of such patients �many of them being patient of depression, which is not covered at present.

Thursday, January 28, 2010

Income tax benefit for those who buy health insurance

Income tax benefit for those who buy health insurance

We can divide this into 3 parts;

1-When you buy the policy for your family - If you are buying the policy for your family; maximum amount can be Rs 15000 under clause 80 D. This is the highest amount which you can cover under the limit of Rs 1.00 lakh.

2-When you pay for health insurance of your parents who are below 65 years; Maximum amount can be Rs 15000. This amount is over and above the limit given to you under 80D.

3- When you pay for health insurance of your parents who are above 65 years; Maximum amount can be Rs 20000. This amount is over and above the limit given to you under 80D

It means that if you are getting the policy for your family as well as your parents who are above 65 years then you are getting rebate on Rs 35000.

If you are in higher tax bracket then this can be 30% of Rs 35000. It means nearly Rs 12000 is being paid by the Government.

Health insurance Cover is a good benefit to retain staff

Large numbers of HR specialists are of the opinion that take home pay is more important for attracting the talent as well retaining the staff.

We have come across survey where top 125 employers comprising a large and varied industry segments were surveyed. The findings are;

Over 40% Indian companies use health care cover for employees as a tool to attract talent and a retention strategy. Rising premium costs have not reduced the importance of health care cover as an employment value differentiator and Indian companies continue to use it as part of their hiring and retention strategy.

Only 11% use it to minimize loses arising out of employee heath issues.
58% companies did not deduct any premium costs out of employee salary, which means that 100% cost is booked by the company as an expense.

Rising health care costs are making are making corporate strive to strike a balance between increasing premium costs and talent management strategies. It is vital that employers design appropriate health care plans, employ efficient ways to manage them and to ensure employees understand their value.

Corporate are constantly devising different strategies to control healthcare costs. Companies are using;
1. Emphasizing on employee education for healthcare.
2. Removing the parents of employees from the coverage as higher premium is being charged by the Insurance companies for covering the parents.

Only 17% companies cover post-retirement medical expenditure, most of which are public sector companies. We foresee that this will be reduced in near future as more and more PSU�s go in for disinvestment and start coming at par with Private companies which are quote on the stock exchange.

This shows that healthcare cover is being provided only for the benefit of the companies and not for the employees. Better health of the employees means better productivity for the company. Also by providing health cover companies save on medical expenditure to be incurred on health of the employees.

Wednesday, January 27, 2010

Early detection of disease can save higher claims, which insurance companies are paying at present

We came across two interesting news items recently which had following information for us:

1. According to AIIMS study 90% women ask for medical help after stage 1 of breast cancer. 70% of women go to their doctors in the 3rd and 4th stages of breast cancer, by when conservation of the organ is very difficult and chances of cancer developing in the other breast are very high. Naturally it means high claim figure to be paid by insurance company as well as pain and agony for the patient.

2. As per a study published in the Journal of Clinical Endocrinology and Metabolism, people with periodontitis are at about 20% greater risk of heart attack. 34% of people with moderate periodontitis and 37% with severe periodontitis had metabolic syndrome, compared to just 18 percent of people with no gum disease or only mild periodontitis.
Metabolic syndrome is a cluster of risk factors for heart disease, paralysis and diabetes, including high blood pressure, abdominal obesity, low levels of �good� HDL cholesterol and high triglycerides (another type of blood fat).

By not covering dental treatment as a part of Health Insurance, most of the insurance companies feel that they are saving lot of money. But if they start paying for dental treatments, maybe they can save higher claims for which they are called upon to pay at a later date.

Insurance companies issue health insurance policies to individuals below the age of 45 years without any medical examination and charge appropriate premium from them. In most of the policies there is provision to pay for the health check up expenses but on the one hand amount to be paid is small and a good effort is involved in reimbursement of the same. The consequence is that most of the insured prefer to forgo the same rather than avail this facility.

From the above mentioned two instances we find that if preventive diseases are detected early, it will be beneficial for both the individual as well as the insurance company.

Some of the suggestions which insurance companies may consider:

  • Create awareness and encourage females to go in for mammography test for examination of breast cancer so that it can be detected in early stages and cured easily with much less costs. Sending SMS/email or even telecalling the insured after the age of 45 years will result in good response. The insured will appreciate this gesture on part of the insurance company.

  • Tie-up with dental surgeons to offer discounts to people who have health insurance policy. No outgo will happen as far as the insurance company is concerned but there will definitely more and more customers coming to Dental Surgeons and hence they will be motivated to give discount as a gesture of goodwill and low cost in getting more customers who will become customers of their clinic.

Friday, January 8, 2010

2 policies of Health insurance �how to lodge claim ?

Preeti Kulkarni has written a good article in The Economic Times of January 6, 2010 on �Take extra cover for sake of your health�

The Heading carries the line �In many cases, claims can be made under both the policies� It is very interesting and has resulted in many calls being received by me from persons who have visit this website.
The same article under the sub heading �Making a claim under two policies.� mentions
�Many policy holders tend to assume that they can file a claim under any of the policies they have signed up for, which may not always be the case; whether the individual can make a choice to claim depends on the provisions made in the policies taken. Also, whether the individual can make a choice to claim depends on the provisions made in the policies taken. Typically, there is a declaration sought from the customer on the policies under which s/he is covered, and the total liability is shared by the insurers, informs.
The contribution clause in the policies states that claims can be made under both the polices, in the same ratio as the sum insured. For instance, if you are covered under a corporate policy with a sum insured of Rs. 2 lakh, in addition to a personal cover of Rs. 1 lakh and makes a claim for Rs. 1 lakh, the insurer servicing the former will contribute around Rs. 66,000 while the balance will come from the other insurer. However, according to Pawan Bhalla, CEO of Rakish TPA, in India, policyholders are not legally bound to disclose the details of any existing policy or make a claim under any of the two policies they are covered under.�

Pawan has mentioned that it is not necessary to make the declaration to both the Insurance Companies.

Reality is that if the claim is of small sum then everything is fine. But if the claim is large and let us say the facts are

Policy 1 Coverage under corporate group policy = Rs. 5 Lakh
Policy 2 Coverage under own policy = Rs. 5 Lakh

Policy 1 was issued in 2003, and is continuing. A claim was lodged in June 2009, for Rs. 2 lakh and was paid.

Policy 2 was issued in November 2008 and is continuing. Insurance company 2 was not informed about existence of policy 1.

Let us say in January 2010 claim is to be lodged for Rs. 7 lakh.

This is the point at which problem like claim settlement arises when the claim is to be lodge with both companies.

As only one set of original documents (Invoice bill / Receipt / Test Reports / Discharge Summary) can be issued by Hospital therefore if will become necessary for the client to reveal to both the companies about details of polices. If any document is required from Insurance Company (Policy 1) they will point out when you took this policy and why we were not informed about policy 2 on earlier occasion as they would have asked Insurance Company 2 to pay half of the claim amount of Rs. 2 Lakh. In most probability Insurance company 1 while paying the claim of Rs. 7 lakhs in ratio of 1;1 which means Rs. 3.50 lakh will deduct Rs. 1 lakh for June 2009 claim.

In the absence of letter from Insurance Company 1 he can not go to Insurance Company 2. Alternatively if lodges original documents with Insurance Company 2 then he may find slightly easier but problem for claim settlement is bound to emerge.

Any effort to get 2 sets of original form Hospital is not suggested as Insurance Co�s / TPA�s are cautious and are trying to control frauds as many cases of multiple claims being lodged with more than 1 Insurance Company have been noticed / reported.

In the end I will like to say you are buying Insurance for having peace of mind then it is better to reveal to both the Insurance Companies about the policy.